Saturday, June 10, 2006

Round 1: Group Photius

See Rules and Instructions.

Ebehard Jüngel vs. John Hick

Rosemary Radford Ruether vs. Joseph Ratzinger

26 comments:

Patrik said...

Hick

RRR

Not because I necesserily agree with Hick but someone has to make the inclusivist case. And Ratzinger may be great theologian, (among other things), but his attitude against his old friend Rahner gives Radford Ruether the point.

Jason said...

Jungel

Ratzinger

andy gr said...

Juengel

Ratzinger

Pontificator said...

This is easy:

Jungel

Ratzinger

TJ said...

John Hick. Not that I agree with him, but at least it's possible to understand what he writes.

Ratzinger.

D.W. Congdon said...

Juengel

Ratzinger

Hick? Please. Those who don't understand Juengel haven't given him a chance.

One of Freedom said...

Jungel

Ruether

I may go to a pontifical school, but I here is where you find out I'm not a Roman.

Jonathan said...

Jungel

Ratzinger

Andy Goodliff said...

Jungel

Ratzinger

Maria said...

Hick

RRR

of course :o)

John P. said...

Hick

Ratzinger

byron said...

Jüngel

Ratzinger

I don't feel I know enough about Ruether to be decisive on the second one, but Ratzinger's influence is well-established, not least through his treatment of the South American liberation theologians. Guess this raises an important criteriological issue: am I voting for my favourite, or for most influential? On this game, I'm just going for influence.

Gaunilo said...

Jungel

Ratzinger cum Benedict XVI

Michael Joseph said...

Juengel

Ratzinger--this isn't even close

Aaron G said...

Hick

Ruether

Dave Barrie said...

Jungel

Ratzinger

dan said...

Jungel.

Ratzinger.

Patrik said...

Half way through the game the standings are:

12 - 5 to Jüngel

and

4 - 13 to Ratzinger

Keep voting

Ben Myers said...

Jüngel

Ratzinger

Shane Clifton said...

Jungel

Ruether

joshua said...

Jungel

Ratzinger

Brian said...

Jungel

Ratzinger

Eduardo said...

Obviously, Jüngel and Ratzinger...

Stijn said...

Jüngel

Ratzinger

Easy.

Patrik said...

Voting Closed.

Patrik said...

Final Results:

19 - 5 to Jüngel

5 - 19 to Ratzinger